Monday, July 25, 2011

... and I Like to Jog Naked


I have struggled with how to approach this topic or if I should even discuss it.  We held my Mother's funeral on July 20th.  It was kind of non-traditional for Utah.  There was a small private viewing held for her close friends and family who could not be with her when she died.  Her children, including myself, did not attend the viewing because we said our goodbyes at her bedside as she struggled with the disease and and eventually died.  We did not need that part of closure.  We held the service at graveside.

I look at funerals somewhat differently than my religious friends and family do.  I don't believe that my loved ones are on the other side waiting for me.  There is simply no evidence this is the case.  So, the funeral is my last opportunity to publicly memorialize my loved ones memory.

My mother had 4 children.  3 are atheists.  My youngest sister is a practicing Mormon.  There had been quite a bit of discussion between my siblings and I, with my mother's input ,as to how we would proceed after her death.  Her wishes were met as were ours.  No one's voice was drowned out and the discussion was civil and all sides were represented.  The plan was: My mother would be buried in a pink dress with her mother's ring.  She made it clear she did not want to be cremated.  She did not care if the coffin was expensive.  She did not want the service in a church.  She did not believe the Mormons had the corner on god and found them to be pushy and judgmental and she did not want her children to be lectured.  If the weather was warm she wanted to service to be graveside.  If the weather was cold she wanted us to have it indoors so those who came to pay respects would not be cold.  She did not want a viewing if we did not want to hold one.  We would not pray at the graveside and there would be no official religious representation.

When we met with the funeral director we outlined what we wanted to have happen and he was extremely helpful in assisting us in meeting those requests.  His compassion and sensitivity were a noted quality and we enjoyed, as much as you can, his assistance and would recommend his company without hesitation.  During our conversations it was clear that there would not be a religious rite of any kind for this funeral.  My   mother's sister asked if they could hold a family prayer at the viewing as they closed the casket.  It was made clear that we did not have a problem with the prayer (we wouldn't be there after all) if it made them feel better but there would be none graveside.

The service was successful.  I conducted.  There was a musical number sung by my daughter Jessica and my sister-in-law Jennifer.  My Aunt Nene read a beautiful poem she wrote for my mother.  I made opening remarks followed by an open mic and concluded with closing remarks offered by me again.  I operated in the capacity that my siblings had requested and expected me to.  By all accounts, the service was beautiful simple and was exactly the type of service my mother wanted.


My Mother's Siblings and their families at her funeral 07/20/2011
So curmudgeon what is the issue?

We had three guests at our little secular funeral who found it necessary to use the open mic as an opportunity to bear their testimonies.  They could not stand the fact we were fine without the mention of the Mormon church or Jesus Christ, the plan of salvation, or even god.   Additionally, the hearse driver pulled me aside.  He told me that he had heard that there might be an anti-religion sentiment to our service.  He told me that he was happy to see that no one was forced out of their beliefs.  He thought it would have been wrong to not allow people to speak.  My mother's siblings attended the funeral in their Wrangler's.  They were dressed informally.  I was dressed in a black suit, white shirt, and red and black tie.  The hearse driver mistook me for the out voted religious minority at the service.  He made a broad assumption that I was a "member of the church" and about shit when he realized he was talking to one of the "angry militant atheists".  I was gracious and let him and the other's say their peace.  I didn't attempt to stop them.  I was non confrontational.

During this process many people have expressed their condolences and a few have had to add that they know my mother is in a better place, is watching down on me, is with her relatives, or is comforting someone else who is recently deceased.  As people would offer their religious views including the afterlife while offering their condolences I found myself turning them off or going somewhere else in my head until they were done while graciously accepting their kindness.  I don't understand why there is an imperative for them to share those things with people who do not want them.  I don't share my atheism unless it is solicited.

My point of this writing is to illustrate how unwanted religious expression is really a two way street.  Imagine, if you will, if I were attending a Mormon funeral and told the guests at the funeral that this is it.  Your loved one is going to rot in the ground and you will never seen them again.  While this is what I believe I have never shared it during a persons most painful or emotional times.  What if I made a point of telling them that they can pray their lives away but there is no one there to hear them.  Would any of those conversations give comfort to a hurting human?  No!  Neither do expressions of faith to an atheist.  My father-in-law put this in perspective to one of my wife's siblings.  He told them, 'you need to understand for Kevin this is it.  There is no more and he will never see his mother again.'  That was an appropriate acknowledgement of what I believed.  He did not offer faith promoting insights to me instead he cried with us and gave us incredible emotional support.

I have said it before, unsolicited expressions of faith are icky.  Faith, like your bedroom habits, should be shared when solicited and with like minded people.... otherwise keep them to yourself.

I think the next time someone offers an unsolicited and otherwise inappropriate expression of faith to me my response is going to be... " ...and I like to jog naked."  Well, as long as were sharing inappropriate information....


6 comments:

  1. My wife and I commented on the drive home about the testimonies. We were not sure if your mother was LDS, but we seemed to recall that she was not. Our thought was that, if she was not, those testimonies were pretty rude.

    Though I do not agree with the thinking that drove them, I understand it. Evangelical thinking is pretty similar. I remember being a young evangelical and being told that I needed to share my faith at every opportunity... people's souls depended on it, and their outcome was my responsibility.

    I remember when I was kid, our church took part in a Christian/Jewish gathering for the Detroit area; my Pastor offended almost everyone there by talking to Jesus the whole time in his closing prayer. One of the organizers was scorching mad, saying my pastor had set back jewish/christian relations in Detroit; but everyone in our church was proud of him for "standing up" for Jesus.

    Even at my young age of, probably 10, I knew what my Pastor did was rude. I couldn't understand how it was helpful to stand for one's faith if it made one rude.

    You however, my friend, were not rude in return and handled their clumsiness with grace.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you Andrew. My mother was not a practicing Mormon. She was baptized but had been mistreated by pious mormons so much in her past she wanted nothing to do with them. She certainly did not want them to usher her out of this world. She had a loose belief in god but was really unable to define what it meant to her. It was a feeling or comfort to her not a tangible belief system or personage.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sorry hear of your loss. My mother passed away almost 4 yrs ago from COPD. She too was on Hospice for the last several months of her life.

    Her funeral was frustrating for me as well. We were never a religious family and she was not a religious person. She did not go to church, never talked about God, and did not own a Bible. For the last several years of her life she lived with my sister and her partner. The partner was religious, with cute little quotes from God all over her house. As a result, my Mother's service was drowned in religion. They played every possible country song that mentioned Jesus or Heaven. It really bothered me that they ignored her entire life and recast her as a devout Christian. Its been 4 years and I'm still pissed.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very sorry for your loss.

    I like your way of explaining two way streets as it relates to religious expression. I've experienced awkward moments among friends, especially back in college. For some of my more devout friends, I finally had to learn to clam up and let they say their peace while internally screaming for them to just shut up already.

    I've always maintained that religious views are a private issue, only to be shared when welcome and with those who are receptive to how I think (of course I live in the Midwest, so that's probably a whole different dynamic than Utah...). When reversed, I try to be the tolerant one while not refuting what I'm hearing. Some people just like to talk about their faith - doesn't mean I have to agree.

    Your situation was different though... I don't see why anyone outside of the family should even try to take ownership of god's role in your mothers funeral. That's disrespectful. I'm glad her wishes could be fulfilled through you and your siblings... it's the best send off you can give her. :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jimbob, I am sorry that you mother's funeral was hijacked in that manner. The only way my mother's could have been more perfect was if those in attendance had put us before themselves like we had for our mother. I will probably harbor some resentment for their intrusion.

    Fiscal, I frequently hear of the arrogant atheists who parade their world view. Atheists are vilified in LDS circles. We are accused of all sorts of trespasses and attempting to steal away faith. I have found that most atheists I know are quiet and respectful of beliefs as long as they are not pushed into the public square. I started this blog because I had no voice for that expression and in fact most folks who know me are surprised to find out that I am an atheist because they cannot reconcile what they have been taught an atheist is and what I am.

    ReplyDelete
  6. 21 years ago my mom killed herself and it fell to me, her baptist preacher son, to cake care of things. We had no service, no viewing, just a graveside service. The grief was heavy and I could barely get through the service. (at the time I thought my mom went to hell) I just wanted to get it over and be done with it. Leave it to my fundamentalist grandfather to start speaking after the benediction about the wonders of Jesus. I wanted to strangle him.He did what he always did and now he is where my mom is..

    Thank you for writing this post and allowing others to enter into your grief.

    ReplyDelete